Closing argument

Closing Argument

(0 ratings)

A sophisticated equal-parts cocktail featuring mezcal, Green Chartreuse, maraschino liqueur, and lime juice for bold, complex flavors.

SUGGESTED GLASSWARE

Coupe Glass

Keep screen on?

Recipe

1 cocktail (120ml)
  • Mezcal 
    22.5 ml
  • Green Chartreuse 
    22.5 ml
  • Maraschino Liqueur 
    22.5 ml
  • Lime Juice 
    22.5 ml
  • Lime 
    1 twist
Recipe credit: Modern Classic

Instructions

Step

Fill coupe glass with ice and set aside to chill while preparing the cocktail.

Step

Measure and add 22.5ml each of mezcal, Green Chartreuse, Luxardo Maraschino Liqueur, and fresh lime juice to cocktail shaker.

Step

Add plenty of ice to shaker and shake vigorously for 10-15 seconds to ensure proper dilution and chilling.

Step

Discard ice from coupe glass and double strain the cocktail using both cocktail strainer and fine strainer.

Step

Garnish with lime twist or maraschino cherry for enhanced aroma and presentation.

Equipment

Shaker
Fine Mesh Strainer
Jigger
Bar spoon

Description

The Closing Argument is a modern classic cocktail that balances smoky mezcal with the herbal complexity of Green Chartreuse, sweet maraschino liqueur, and bright lime juice. This equal-parts drink creates a sophisticated harmony of flavors that appeals to adventurous cocktail enthusiasts seeking bold, complex taste profiles.

Nutritional information

1 cocktail (120ml)
Calories
185
ABV
22 %
Alcohol
21 g
Carbs
8 g
Carbs from Sugar
6 g
Fat
0 g
Protein
0.2 g
Sodium
2 mg
Nutritional information is approximate and includes estimated 30% dilution from ice. Values may vary based on specific brands and preparation methods.
Allergens
Sulfites

Tips & Notes

  • Use freshly squeezed lime juice for optimal flavor - bottled juice will compromise the cocktail's bright acidity.

  • Choose a high-quality mezcal for smoother, less harsh smokiness that won't overpower the other ingredients.

  • Chill your coupe glass thoroughly for a crisp, refreshing experience that maintains the cocktail's temperature longer.

  • Shake hard and double strain to ensure proper dilution and silky texture - this cocktail benefits from vigorous preparation.

  • The equal parts ratio is crucial - use precise measuring tools rather than free-pouring for consistent results.

While tequila can be substituted, it will significantly change the character of the drink. Mezcal’s smokiness is essential to the Closing Argument’s flavor profile. If using tequila, choose a reposado for more complexity.

Green Chartreuse is preferred for its higher proof and more intense herbal flavor. Yellow Chartreuse is sweeter and milder, which would alter the cocktail’s balance, though it can work as a substitute if that’s what you have available.

The fresh lime juice requires shaking to properly integrate with the other ingredients and achieve the right dilution. The vigorous shaking also helps bind the diverse flavors together and creates the proper texture.

Double straining is crucial for achieving the silky, refined texture that makes this cocktail special. It removes ice chips and pulp that would otherwise affect both mouthfeel and appearance.

Related Herbal, Smoky, Sour cocktails

Sea Legs

A sophisticated modern classic combining peated whisky, mezcal, almond orgeat, and lime with savory celery bitters for a complex smoky-sour experience.

Sea legs

Naked and Famous

A modern classic equal-parts cocktail featuring smoky mezcal, herbal yellow Chartreuse, bitter-sweet Aperol, and fresh lime juice

Naked and famous

Leave your comment

Cocktail Difficulty Levels

We’ve added a difficulty rating to every cocktail so you’ll know what to expect before you start mixing. It’s not about being “hard” or “easy” in the strict sense—it’s about how much preparation, skill, and hunting for ingredients you’ll need.

  • Beginner – Quick builds or simple shakes with common ingredients you’ll likely already have at home. Perfect for beginners or a casual evening.

  • Intermediate – A bit more technique (stirring, shaking, muddling, layering) and a few extra ingredients. You might need to buy one or two bottles or garnishes you don’t already stock.

  • Advanced – Multiple steps, specialty techniques (infusions, syrups, foams), or rare ingredients. These drinks take more effort and planning, but reward you with something truly impressive.

The rating is based on things like the number of ingredients, how rare they are, and the skills needed to bring the cocktail together.

Okay

Recipe notes

Create a free account 

My Bar, saved forever
Without an account, your ingredients are only stored in cookies and can disappear. With an account, your bar is saved securely – so you can always see which recipes you can craft (or almost craft) based on what you have at home.

Rate recipes
Share your opinion and help other cocktail lovers discover the best recipes.

Favourites at your fingertips
Save your go-to cocktails for quick access right from your account page.

Personal notes
Add your own tweaks, tips, or reminders to any recipe – perfect if you like to experiment or record what worked best.

Exclusive newsletter
Opt-in for insights into mixology, cocktail theory, and home bartending – plus stay updated when new recipes are added.

Quick recipe

Ingredients

  • Mezcal
    22.5 ml
  • Green Chartreuse
    22.5 ml
  • Maraschino Liqueur
    22.5 ml
  • Lime Juice
    22.5 ml
  • Lime
    1 twist

Method

  1. Fill coupe glass with ice and set aside to chill while preparing the cocktail.
  2. Measure and add 22.5ml each of mezcal, Green Chartreuse, Luxardo Maraschino Liqueur, and fresh lime juice to cocktail shaker.
  3. Add plenty of ice to shaker and shake vigorously for 10-15 seconds to ensure proper dilution and chilling.
  4. Discard ice from coupe glass and double strain the cocktail using both cocktail strainer and fine strainer.
  5. Garnish with lime twist or maraschino cherry for enhanced aroma and presentation.